PI Global Investments
Real Estate

Good tool, bad broker: What I’ve learned about AI in commercial real estate


Not long ago, a client sent me five addresses. All five were supposedly on the market and lined up on price, use and location, which would give us something to counter with. If that was true, we needed to take a serious look. Then they told me where the list came from: ChatGPT.

So I started checking. Some were off market. Some were expired listings. One of them flat out didn’t exist. There was no building at that address because ChatGPT made it up. Out of five properties, not one was actually available.

I’m not writing this to bash AI. I use it all the time. But more and more of my clients are bringing it into our conversations, whether that’s negotiating, lease terms, contracts or what’s on the market, so it’s worth talking about where it helps and where it can burn you.

 

Why I’m Not Anti-AI

My bachelor’s degree is in computer information and business analytics, so I like this stuff, and I have a pretty good idea of how it works. As a commercial broker in Grand Junction, working across retail, industrial, office, land and multifamily, I also see what it looks like when it runs into a real deal. For the easy stuff, it’s great. It cleans up my emails, summarizes long documents, organizes data and gets me a first draft in a fraction of the time.

 

It Will Make Things Up

Here’s what most people don’t realize. Tools like ChatGPT are built to predict what a good answer should look like, based on patterns in a massive amount of text. When it doesn’t really know the answer, it usually won’t tell you that. It fills the gap with something that sounds right, and it sounds just as confident when it’s wrong. It isn’t lying on purpose, but the result can look a lot like a lie.

This goes well beyond real estate. In 2023, a federal judge in New York fined two attorneys and their firm $5,000 after they filed a brief citing court cases that ChatGPT had invented. If it can fool lawyers with fake case law, it can fool anybody with a fake listing.

It Wants to Agree With You

The other issue is bias, and this one’s harder to catch. These tools learn in part from human feedback, and people tend to like hearing they’re right. So AI leans toward agreeing with you. In 2025, OpenAI actually rolled back a ChatGPT update after admitting it had become too flattering and agreeable.

Think about how that plays out in a deal. Ask it why your building is worth $2 million, and it’ll give you a list of reasons. Ask it whether a landlord’s offer is unfair, and it’ll probably find something wrong with it. You walk into the negotiation feeling great about a position nobody has actually tested. A good broker will tell you when your number is off, even when you don’t want to hear it. AI is a lot less likely to.

What It Can’t See

Even when AI isn’t making something up, a lot of what matters in commercial real estate isn’t online. A space that’s about to open up before it’s listed, a landlord who’d take less for the right tenant, what an owner actually cares about: That comes from relationships and from being in this market every day.

Lease comps are a good example. Asking rent is easy to find, but what a space actually leased for usually isn’t. I’ve had AI hand me a comp using the asking rent instead of the signed rent, off by more than 80 cents a foot. I caught it, but it would have been easy to miss. Contracts are similar. AI can explain a clause in plain English, which is genuinely useful, but it doesn’t know your deal, and it doesn’t replace your broker or your attorney.

Use It, Then Check It

So my advice is simple: Use it. Let it draft the email, summarize the lease or explain what NNN means. Just treat it like a sharp new intern who works fast and still needs their work checked. If it gives you an address, look it up. If it gives you a number, find out where it came from. If it says a term is “market,” run it by someone doing deals here. And ask it what’s wrong with your idea, not just to back you up.

I’d much rather have a client show up with good questions because of AI than with no questions at all. So bring me what you find. Just let somebody check it before you put your money behind it.

Matthew Parker is a commercial broker for Bray Commercial Real Estate.



Source link

Related posts

Avatar Capital Partners: $156 Million First Close For Fund II With GCM Grosvenor And Teacher Retirement System Of Texas

D.William

Park Madison’s Lashine: ‘Promotes are gone, people are moving’ – PERE

D.William

IRFU pitches major hotel plan beside Aviva Stadium

D.William

Leave a Comment