55.58 F
May 26, 2024
PI Global Investments

Bitcoin ruling ignites crypto row: Fans say it could hit $1.5m – critics say it’s ‘fraud, with a veneer of respectability’

Bitcoin raced to its highest level in two years yesterday after US regulators gave the world’s most popular crypto-currency a toehold in the mainstream financial world.

The approval by America’s Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) of exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that track the crypto-currency’s price was hailed as a breakthrough.

Yet sceptics maintain that bitcoin, which unlike other popular assets has no inherent value, ‘could drain your bank account’.

Approval: Bitcoin soared to $49,000, the highest since December 2021, and prompted extravagant predictions that it could rise as high as $1.5m

Approval: Bitcoin soared to $49,000, the highest since December 2021, and prompted extravagant predictions that it could rise as high as $1.5m

Yesterday was a day for bitcoin bulls, however, as its price soared to $49,000, the highest since December 2021, and prompted extravagant predictions that it could rise as high as $1.5million.

It later fell back, but that did little to dent enthusiasm for an industry critics maintain is akin to the Wild West.

The SEC approved 11 ETFs with big mainstream financial institutions such as Blackrock and Fidelity among those behind them. 

It was seen as a watershed moment for an asset that has lacked an endorsement by the authorities.

The SEC’s authorisation was not exactly that. Chairman Gary Gensler said: ‘Investors should remain cautious about the myriad risks associated with bitcoin and products whose value is tied to crypto.’

> Will bitcoin ETFs send prices higher – and what does this mean? Watch Lunch Money on This is Money’s YouTube channel

‘Fraud, given a veneer of respectability’ 

But there was anger in the City that the SEC went too far. ‘Fraud. Now given a veneer of respectability,’ said Panmure Gordon’s chief economist Simon French.

He said it was a ‘shocking dereliction of duty from regulators’.

Bitcoin is derided by mainstream financial commentators because it holds no inherent value. 

And it has often been associated with shady practices such as usage by criminals to move money around covertly.

Key ruling: SEC Chairman Gary Gensler

Key ruling: SEC Chairman Gary Gensler

Yet there are those who argue that it shares some similarities with gold – an investment that does not yield any earnings but may be held as part of a portfolio of investments which holds value at times of volatility.

Unlike gold, bitcoin does not exist in any physical form. Bitcoin, which came into existence in 2008, has also been volatile.

It hit a high of nearly $69,000 in 2021 before sinking as low as $16,000 in 2022 after the implosion of crypto exchange FTX.

But in recent months its value has surged amid speculation the SEC decision was coming.

$200,000 next year… $1.5million by 2030 – the wild bitcoin predictions

Standard Chartered analyst Geoff Kendrick thinks it could hit $100,000 this year and could double 12 months after that.

In a note this week, he said: ‘If ETF-related inflows materialise as we expect, we think an end-2025 level closer to $200,000 is possible.’ 

Cathie Wood, founder of Ark Investments, which is behind one of the funds, said it could reach $1.5million by 2030.

In Britain, regulators have yet to soften their resistance.

Last year, Sheldon Mills, executive director for consumers and competition at the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), said crypto ‘remains largely unregulated and high risk’ and that ‘those who invest should be prepared to lose all their money’.

What the bitcoin ETF approval means 

The SEC approval does not mean the ETFs can be marketed or made available in the UK. 

It would be unlikely to be available to ordinary investors. But it is possible for UK investors to buy it through a trading platform.

FCA figures from 2022 suggest nearly 5m UK adults own crypto assets – 10 per cent of adults.

An ETF is a simple way for investors to gain exposure to an asset, such as gold, without having to buy them and can be traded like stocks.

Until now, US investors have had to buy bitcoin either using a secure ‘cold wallet’ that allows crypto to be held offline, or by opening a trading account with a platform such as Coinbase or Binance.

‘The approval has the potential to simplify and secure bitcoin investments for a broader investor base,’ said Rajeev Bamra, at Moody’s Investors Service.

Yet while the approval seemed to mark a coming of age as a financial asset, it arrived in characteristically chaotic style – after the SEC Twitter/X account was hacked and announced approval a day early.

‘Bitcoin may be gaining a shade more legitimacy, but it’s still showing all the hallmarks of a troublesome teenager,’ said Susannah Streeter, at Hargreaves Lansdown.

‘It’s an unpredictable and volatile investment that could drain your bank account.’

A ‘watershed’ bitcoin moment… but be careful what you wish for 


The launch of the bitcoin ETF is being described as a ‘watershed moment’.

Suddenly crypto-currencies seem to be stepping out of a scandal-ridden past into semi-respectability. The launch of 11 funds by US giants like Blackrock and Fidelity could almost give the impression they are mainstream.

Not long ago, buying crypto used to be prompted largely by a fear of missing out, amplified by social media messaging.

Cathie Wood, the US fund manager who believes bitcoin is ‘a public good’, says US savers have ‘democratised access to innovation’. But funds will not give exposure to the blockchain ledger technology that underlies crypto-currencies. Blockchain’s possibilities truly are infinite.

The SEC’s decision highlighted bitcoin’s volatility – and may aggravate this. The digital currency was trading at close to $50,000 yesterday, against a peak of $69,000 in November 2021. 

It tumbled to $16,000 in December 2022 amid the collapse of the FTX exchange whose catastrophic operations confirmed worst suspicions about crypto.

There will be calls for the UK watchdog, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), to make bitcoin funds available to British investors who cannot, for regulatory reasons, buy the US funds.

It will be argued such arrangements will end the risk of holding crypto directly.

But those who agitate for such funds should be careful what they wish for. Lindsay James strategist at Quilter Investors reminds us: ‘Bitcoin remains an incredibly speculative product.’

Ben Yearsley of Fairview Investing says: ‘Bitcoin isn’t a real currency, it isn’t backed by any government and isn’t particularly easy to spend.

‘It isn’t a store of value like gold – so what purpose does it hold?’

If you would still like a stake in a bitcoin ETF, then it may still be possible.

Jason Hollands of Bestinvest thinks some multi-asset UK funds will take stakes. But there is a broader issue here.

The SEC’s move reflects confidence in the financial literacy of Americans, trusting that millions will hold back from sinking all their life savings in crypto. The general level of knowledge in Britain is far lower.

As a result, the FCA would be concerned that bitcoin funds would leave millions of people ruined, or ‘rekt’ as they say in crypto slang.

Whatever your views on bitcoin, it is a shame that a lack of financial education in our schools means that we cannot be treated like grown-ups.

Some links in this article may be affiliate links. If you click on them we may earn a small commission. That helps us fund This Is Money, and keep it free to use. We do not write articles to promote products. We do not allow any commercial relationship to affect our editorial independence.

Source link

Related posts

Over 200K Bitcoins Worth $9 Bln On Move Causes Panic, What’s Happening?


Is this Bitcoin bull run different? Key indicators say…


Over 2 percent of the US’s electricity generation now goes to bitcoin


Leave a Comment

* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.