Mortgage REIT yields north of 15% look like a retiree’s dream, until one CEO admits his dividend may not survive. Three lenders promise monthly-bill relief, but only one has the earnings to back up its payout.
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Retirees who no longer draw a paycheck still have monthly bills, which leads many to become investors and start with the highest-yield corner of the stock market: mortgage real estate investment trusts, or mortgage REITs.
A regular REIT owns buildings and collects rent. A mortgage REIT owns home loans, commercial loans, and mortgage bonds and collects the interest on them. Most of that money is borrowed, which makes the income bigger.
Here’s what a $20,000 stake in each of these three lenders would return. That’s $60,000 in total, and it works out to $8,554 a year in dividends. The yields are high for a structural reason: REITs have to pay out roughly 90%+ of their taxable income to keep their tax status, and leverage amplifies what’s left to distribute. Prices are from the Nov. 6, 2026 close, and yields are forward yields.
Rithm Capital
- Stock #3: Rithm Capital (NYSE:RITM)
- Yield: 10.83%
- Shares for $20,000: 2,166.8 at $9.23
- Annual Passive Income: ~$2,167
Rithm is a mortgage company structured as a REIT. Its Newrez unit makes and services home loans, meaning it collects borrowers’ payments for whoever owns the loans. Newrez services $878.9 billion in unpaid principal balance. Rithm also runs Sculptor and Crestline, two asset managers with about $61B under management.
Third-quarter adjusted EPS came in at $0.55, enough to cover the $0.25 quarterly dividend. That payout hasn’t changed since the October 2021 ex-date. Earlier, though, Rithm cut its dividend from $0.50 in 2019 to $0.05 in 2020. Book value, meaning assets minus debts per share, stood at $12.51. A key concern is that the value of its servicing rights moves with interest rates.
Starwood Property Trust
- Stock #2: Starwood Property Trust (NYSE:STWD)
- Yield: 15.95%
- Shares for $20,000: 1,661.1 at $12.04
- Annual Passive Income: ~$3,189
Starwood makes loans on commercial real estate, and that book reached $17.8B. It also lends to energy and infrastructure projects, owns properties such as the Woodstar affordable housing portfolio, and runs LNR, a special servicer that works out troubled loans.
Starwood has paid $0.48 every quarter since 2014. Distributable earnings, its measure of cash available to pay out, were only $0.31 in the third quarter, or $0.41 before realized loan losses.
Chairman and CEO Barry Sternlicht said, “I think we will have to examine what we are going to do with our dividend.” The 15.95% yield assumes the current payout holds. A $336.6M credit loss provision shows the risk from borrowers struggling with higher rates. Undepreciated book value was $17.22 per share.
Annaly Capital Management
- Stock #1: Annaly Capital Management (NYSE:NLY)
- Yield: 15.99%
- Shares for $20,000: 1,066.1 at $18.76
- Annual Passive Income: ~$3,198
Annaly mostly buys agency mortgage-backed securities. These bonds are backed by home loans, and government-sponsored agencies guarantee the payments. It also holds residential credit, such as whole loans bought through its Onslow Bay channel, plus mortgage servicing rights. It earns the gap between what those assets yield and what it pays to borrow.
Annaly raised its quarterly dividend from $0.70 to $0.75 as of the June 2026 ex-date. Third-quarter earnings available for distribution came to $0.80, more than enough to cover it. CEO David Finkelstein said, “The current portfolio delivers the dividend.”
Annaly has cut its payout before, though, going from $0.45 to $0.30 during 2013. Book value fell to $17.86 from $20.15 in one quarter as rate moves hit its bonds.
Taxes and the Book Value Catch
Payouts like these depend on interest rates, borrowing costs, and book value. Yields this high signal risk. The IRS treats ordinary dividends as ordinary income, and most REIT payouts fall into that bucket.
The qualified business income deduction allows individuals to deduct 20% of qualified REIT dividends under 26 U.S.C. § 199A(b)(1)(B). Inside a traditional IRA, the tax comes later, when withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income, which is why many income investors keep REITs in retirement accounts.
| Name | Yield | Annual Dividend Income |
|---|---|---|
| Rithm Capital | 10.83% | $2,167 |
| Starwood Property Trust | 15.95% | $3,189 |
| Annaly Capital Management | 15.99% | $3,198 |
| Total | 14.26% | $8,554 |
Together, these three positions would produce $8,554 a year in passive income from a $60,000 investment, for a blended yield of 14.26%. Annaly contributes $3,198, Starwood adds $3,189, and Rithm chips in $2,167. On average, that’s about $713 a month.
Book value per share is the number to check every quarter, because a falling book usually comes before a smaller dividend. None of these payouts are guaranteed, and Starwood has already said it’s reviewing its dividend.
A double-digit yield usually means the market suspects something, and we listed the seven warning signs that a big payout is about to be cut in a free report here. Quarterly checks that arrive whether stock prices rise or fall can still help cover recurring expenses, as long as the lenders paying them stay healthy.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.