PI Global Investments
Finance

Public finance system is neither limitless nor a mystery


Comment: Before the next finance minister finds themselves in the hot seat, they ought to understand how New Zealand’s public finance system operates. We all should. Our democracy would be stronger if we did.

Our understanding of how the system operates is incorrect. These incorrect assumptions help to embed austerity which, in turn, leads to designed failures in our public resources, such as health and education.

The normal story is simple and goes something like this. Governments of all stripes tax then spend. Income from taxation fills the government’s accounts. If the government spends over its income – what we can call a deficit – then it takes on debt. At some point in the future, those that have lent to government will lose faith in its ability to repay what it borrowed. This leaves one final option. The central bank can lend to the government just like a normal bank would lend to us. The criticism of this idea is that it undermines confidence in money and that leads to inflation and eventual economic collapse.

These ideas make sense. On the face of it, they follow familiar logic that we can’t really argue with. We can call these three ideas the three sources view – where government gets its money from three different sources. These ideas are as old as the hills and appear incredibly obvious. Needless to say, these are the ideas that guide our politics. They are also embedded in our legislation, namely section 26G of the Public Finance Act.

To argue with these ideas, and to think that we have incorrect assumptions about how our public finance system operates, is to argue with common sense itself.

But what if these ideas are wrong?

One way to test this is by simply understanding how government spending works. In doing so, we can clearly see that government spending does not operate like we think it does. Of course, understanding this is easier said than done. There’s a complex tapestry of procedures that underpin this system. In the simplest way possible: every dollar the government spends is a new dollar. Government spending isn’t dependent on funds received from taxpayers or bond markets. Government spending is dependent on Parliament. We can call this the one source view.

Government spending starts with Parliament. It authorises what you and I know as the Budget. While Budgets are extremely important policy documents in their own right, one of their key characteristics is that they determine how much money government departments can spend. This act simultaneously authorises and enables the crediting of government bank accounts. Government bank accounts are ‘funded by way of appropriation’ – they are funded by Parliament. Critically, this account crediting process occurs independently of any receipts the government has received in the past. Every day is a new day. Every dollar is a new dollar.

We can be certain about this. This is because accounts involved in government transactions start and end the day with zero balances (or at least net zero balances). In other words, government spending quite literally starts and ends the day at zero. One part of this process occurs between Westpac and the Treasury eight times a day (or as required), and ensures that government spending or taxing has no impact on Westpac’s balance sheet. We can call this ‘net zeroing’. These processes happen like clockwork, and demonstrate that today’s income is not required for tomorrow’s expenditure.

Finally, because of the design of our public finance system, we can be sure of one peculiar but rather profound fact. Government spending will always happen before funds have been spent from its ‘bank account’ at the Reserve Bank – the Crown Settlement Account. The balance of the Crown Settlement Account is made up of proceeds from taxes and government debt.

So, with Parliament being the source of government finance and the government spending first by design, does this mean we can throw infinite money at things to fix them? Of course not. The government faces resource constraints on, for example, nurses, building materials, or equipment required to operate adequate public goods. Irresponsibility with real resources (ie using more resources than the economy can provide) can lead to negative economic outcomes.

Understanding these mechanics also does not delegitimise the view that government should restrict the size of its spending. Limiting the size of government is an ideological perspective and should be debated as such. Clearly, it is not a matter of fact that the government will ‘run out of money’, and this doesn’t change from Willis to Brown, or Brown to Edmonds, or Edmonds to Swarbrick.  

The reality is that if Parliament has approved spending, then that spending is bound to happen. A good example of this is everyone’s favourite bogeyman – repaying government debt. The data shows that the Crown Settlement Account has been negative 272 times since November 1997. It went negative for seven out of 17 bond maturities (debt repayments) during that period. Crucially, Parliament had permanently approved every single dollar that will be used to pay back debt. This insight challenges regular perceptions of ‘repaying the debt’ and the implications for future generations. This is especially interesting when you realise this data has not been made public before 2026.

By understanding our public finance system, the policy focus shifts from thinking about the health of the government’s books to thinking about resource constraints and the broader health of our economy. If every dollar the government spends is a new dollar, then why base our politics on the idea that the government can run out of dollars? For example, instead of the supposed public debt burden for our grandchildren, what burden will the inability to provide sufficient public resources have on future generations?

While this shift seems simple enough, it has profound consequences for how we conduct our politics and our economy. Our politics should be more than a perpetual talkfest on the best way to limit government spending. All government spending starts from zero, and we can see that it does.

The challenges we face, including the infrastructure crisis, productivity crisis, child poverty crisis, cost of living crisis, homelessness crisis and health care crisis, coupled with an understanding of how government spending works, invite us to step out of our comfort zones and engage more critically with government spending.

The question is, are we ready to make that leap?



Source link

Related posts

Artificial Intelligence and Public Debt: Why Growth Is Not Enough

D.William

Blueprint Finance Announces Strategic Funding Round to Scale Concrete’s Institutional DeFi Infrastructure

D.William

In final budget speech as CM, Picardo defends record and dismisses GSD’s ‘scaremongering’

D.William

Leave a Comment